For Good’ By no means Fairly Flies

Followers of the original Wicked are, undoubtedly, going to fall for Wicked: For Good. The second half of the story picks up a few years later and brings the story of Glinda the Good (Ariana Grande) and Elphaba, the Depraved Witch of the West (Cynthia Erivo), to a giant, rousing conclusion with all of the beautiful visuals, costumes, and results you fell in love with within the first movie. The issue, nonetheless, is that For Good doesn’t do much beyond that. It’s pushed by a stretched-out, repetitive narrative that lacks the innocence and discovery of the primary movie whereas additionally being darker and fewer enjoyable. That’s actually the purpose, but it surely makes this sequel pale compared to the unique.

When final we left the wonderful world of Oz, Elphaba had totally embraced her powers as a witch and left Glinda uncertain of her future, whereas the entire of Oz remained clueless concerning the powerless evil of its Wizard, performed by Jeff Goldblum. Depraved: For Good picks up some obscure period of time after that, which is a little bit complicated as a result of not a lot has modified initially. (There’s a fleeting point out of “12 tide turns,” which appears to counsel 12 years, but it surely’s not one thing that’s given sufficient weight or readability to land in an impactful approach). Elphaba remains to be attempting to show that the Wizard is dangerous and save Oz, whereas Glinda remains to be caught between her desires and her buddy. They’re each virtually precisely the identical, besides now every is far more well-known.

Mainly, the world round these two characters has modified a bit, however neither of them has, which immediately places For Good at a drawback. The primary movie left issues with such excessive stakes about the place these characters might go. So, while you understand neither has achieved something of be aware in such a very long time, it’s a clue that there aren’t a ton of locations for this story to go. Every merely has to do one or two issues to attain their objectives, and but, they haven’t. How does that get stretched right into a full film? How for much longer can they delay the inevitable?

Presumably, writers Winnie Holzman and Dana Fox, together with director Jon M. Chu, are merely following the broader narrative created by the unique stage manufacturing. The problem is, while you see Depraved on stage, you don’t depart for a yr throughout intermission. The whole lot works higher when it’s brisker in your thoughts and fewer cinematic. This adaptation actually suffers from not spending a little bit extra time protecting what has occurred because the final movie. As a substitute, it dives again in as if nothing has occurred, which makes issues each complicated and immediately repetitive.

You’re left scratching your head about how characters like Elphaba’s sister Nessa (Marissa Bode), their faculty buddy Boq (Ethan Slater), and shared love curiosity Fiyero (Jonathan Bailey) bought to their new roles. What occurred that made Glinda go from schoolgirl to this new megastar? Has Elphaba actually made no headway in a decade?

With so little context, these tales and questions simply circle spherical and spherical, placing Depraved: For Good right into a sample. A giant occasion occurs. Elphaba reveals up. Glinda steps in. There’s an motion scene, a reconciliation, after which that repeats. Every time, the story inches ahead at a comically gradual tempo. A few of these motion scenes present a lift, giving the movie a distinct really feel from its predecessor, however we aren’t watching Depraved for the preventing or flying.

We could, nonetheless, be looking ahead to the music. Many of the songs in For Good do a positive job of explaining what’s taking place or attempting to push these characters ahead, however only a few are as memorable or highly effective as songs from the primary half like “The Wizard and I,” “Widespread,” or “Defying Gravity.” The exception is the titular “For Good,” which is available in close to the tip of the film when it lastly decides to maneuver issues forward in a significant approach. It’s a stunning, intimate second between the characters, and it actually drives dwelling simply what every has gone by way of. Up till then, although, the long-running debate of which half of Depraved has the higher songs feels cemented by For Good. The reply? Not this one.

Irrespective of which facet of that debate you fall on, although, the songs are one place the place Erivo and Grande proceed to shine. Every is simply so effortlessly current and charismatic of their performances. We noticed a number of that within the first movie, but it surely continues right here as every—ultimately—has to make some life-changing, tough choices. Of the 2, it’s Grande particularly who rises above. Glinda’s story has extra shades of gray to play with than Elphaba’s, and Grande does a fantastic job of letting us really feel that battle. Her efficiency is undoubtedly the brilliant spot in an in any other case murky film.

One other spotlight is the entire Wizard of Oz-ness to the movie. Probably the most thrilling selections each this movie and the unique musical made is making this story a bigger puzzle that the characters and story of the unique 1939 film can match into. So, in a really Again to the Future Half II approach, it’s extremely rewarding to find how each Glinda and particularly Elphaba influence that story, even when it doesn’t all fairly match collectively. The massive draw back, although, is that this movie predisposes you to have seen and know the 1939 Wizard of Oz extremely effectively, which, hopefully, most of us have. In the event you haven’t, it’s possible you’ll be left scratching your head greater than under no circumstances these items about Toto, Kansas, buckets of water, and tornadoes.

Ultimately, we discovered Depraved: For Good to be an odd film. There are moments the place the performances and visuals actually hit dwelling and produce all of it collectively. However, most of the time, we had been left disillusioned at how little within the movie was as memorable or particular as that first half, or different fantasy movies for that matter. Depraved: For Good doesn’t seem like, however all the time looks like, a by-the-numbers, A-to-Z conclusion of this story, with prolonged moments that draw it out to function size. In Half One, we regularly felt that making Depraved two motion pictures was the precise alternative. Now, having seen For Good, it appears possibly it wasn’t.

However, once more, most of that received’t matter to followers who’re simply dying to see this world, these actors, and these characters once more. That stuff is all proper on level. We simply want it had been within the service of a extra highly effective, attention-grabbing, cohesive, and full story.

Depraved: For Good is in theaters November 21.

Need extra io9 information? Try when to anticipate the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and all the things that you must find out about the way forward for Doctor Who.